
PLOT SUMMARY:
Fallon is a fixer. From planning prom to organizing her college applications, she’s got it all figured out…except for when her younger sister comes to her with very basic questions about sex. Shocked that she knows so little—and her fellow classmates even less—Fallon decides some practical education is in order. And Fallon isn’t above practicing a little civil disobedience by creating a secret underground off-campus group.
Shelby is a fighter. Having her nose broken is nothing new in her semiprofessional career…but this time it’s her boyfriend who threw the punch. Now her phone is blowing up with texts from a new guy who tells her she’s perfect, she’s special, she’s everything he’s ever wanted…except for a few small details. Shelby’s happy to adjust for him, because isn’t that what a healthy relationship is about?
Jobie is a failure. She doesn’t have enough followers and her posts never go viral, no matter how hard she crushes challenges and applies exactly the right filter. But a friendly DM from a good girl just like her points her in the direction of a whole new audience of admirers. Guys who just want to talk. Guys who give her the attention she’s always wanted.
The lives of all three girls intersect in Fallon’s secret class, rumors of which have parents up in arms. Fallon needs to keep herself anonymous, Shelby needs to keep her new boyfriend happy, and Jobie needs to keep her followers…who keep asking for more. Each girl finds herself trapped in an inescapable situation—that will leave one of them dead.
GRADE: B-
REVIEW:
Mindy McGinnis has been an auto-buy author for me for years — I absolutely love her writing and the bold stories she tells. That said, How Girls Are Made didn’t hook me the way her previous books have.
Set against the backdrop of a society that still struggles with how it defines and disciplines girlhood, the plot is timely and unflinching. McGinnis explores themes of bodily autonomy, trauma, identity, and power, all through the lens of a young girl navigating a system that often fails those who need the most protection. As always, her writing pulls no punches. It’s raw, honest, and at times difficult to read, but that’s exactly what makes it so impactful.
The themes are incredibly timely and important, and McGinnis never shies away from tough topics. But the pacing felt slow for much of the book, and it didn’t really hit its stride until about 90% in. That final stretch is powerful, though, and it’s what ultimately makes me recommend this one, especially for teen readers who can benefit from the message.
The characters are complex and real, whose voices ring with authenticity and strength even in their most vulnerable moments. McGinnis never talks down to her readers; instead, she challenges them to confront harsh truths with empathy and open eyes.
In an era where conversations about gender, control, and justice are more urgent than ever, How Girls Are Made couldn’t be more timely. It’s not an easy read, but it’s an important one.
Not my favorite from her, but still worth the read. Highly recommended for readers who appreciate bold storytelling with something to say.
*Thank you so much to NetGalley & Harper Collins for a digital copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!

DID YOU ENJOY WHAT YOU JUST READ? IF YES, THEN SUBSCRIBE TO THE BLOG, GIVE THE POST A LIKE, OR LEAVE A COMMENT! NEW POSTS ARE UP EVERY TUESDAY & THURSDAY!










