
They were always liars.
PLOT SUMMARY:
The invitation arrives out of the blue.
In it, Matilda discovers a father she’s never met. Kingsley Cello is a visionary, a reclusive artist. And when he asks her to spend the summer at his seaside home, Hidden Beach, Matilda expects to find a part of herself she’s never fully understood.
Instead, she finds Meer, her long-lost, openhearted brother; Brock, a former child star battling demons; and brooding, wild Tatum, who just wants her to leave their crumbling sanctuary.
With Kingsley nowhere to be seen, Matilda must delve into the twisted heart of Hidden Beach to uncover the answers she’s desperately craving. But secrets run thicker than blood, and blood runs like seawater.
And everyone here is lying.
GRADE: A-
REVIEW:
I adored E. Lockhart’s We Were Liars and Family of Liars, so I dove into We Fell Apart with high expectations. And while the mystery definitely kept me intrigued, the overall experience didn’t quite hit the same highs—mostly because I just couldn’t connect with the main character, Matilda.
The premise is promising: Matilda leaves sunny California to spend part of her summer vacation at a mysterious castle in Hidden Beach, finally hoping to meet her elusive painter father, Kingsley. But when she arrives? No Kingsley. Just a crumbling castle full of secrets.
While the setup had me curious, Matilda as a protagonist fell flat for me. Her sudden romance with one of the boys felt way too rushed and kind of came out of nowhere. That said, I did really enjoy her dynamic with her half-brother, Meer—he’s a total scene-stealer, and I found myself looking forward to every moment he was on the page.
One of the coolest things about We Fell Apart is its unexpected connection to the Sinclair family from the previous books. I won’t spoil how, but it’s subtle, smart, and gives longtime fans something to chew on by the end.
If you’re already invested in the world of We Were Liars, this book is definitely worth the read. You can read it as a standalone (Lockhart gives you just enough context), but the experience is richer if you’ve read the previous books.
Not my favorite in the series, but still worth picking up for the atmospheric mystery and those trademark Lockhart twists.
*Thank you so much to NetGalley and Delacorte Press for the digital copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!

DID YOU ENJOY WHAT YOU JUST READ? IF YES, THEN SUBSCRIBE TO THE BLOG, GIVE THE POST A LIKE, OR LEAVE A COMMENT! NEW POSTS ARE UP EVERY TUESDAY & THURSDAY!











